Friday, November 6, 2009

July 26th Review

Title: July 26th
Author: Star-chan
Status: Completed
Reviewer: precious_star32 @ Untouchable Desires

Title: 5/5
The title fits your story well. It makes the readers think why is your title July 26?
Forewords: 9/10
I really like how you write your forewords. When I first read your forewords, I know that your story is really nice.
First Impression: 9/10
The poster is atrractive as well as the background. It matches your story. The title of your story makes the readers really curious. I like the title. My first impression on your story was, I started to question myself. Why is it July 26. So when I started reading it until the end, I finally got my answer.
Plot/Storyline: 13/15
Your story is quite unique. Although at first I was quite bored but your story is nice.
Flow: 5/5
The flow of your story is just right. So no problem with that.
Creativity/Originality: 10/10
Since your story is based on a true story, i consider this original.
Grammar/Spelling/Vocabulary/Punctuation: 12/15
You made a few mistakes though. Like you started with the conjunction "but".
You wrote: We were the same age and in the same class. But I still saw her from time to time.
It should be: We were the same age and in the same class, but I still saw her from time to time.
It would have been better if you wrote it this way...
You wrote: We went our separate ways, you walking your own path. I was walking mine.
It should be: We went our separate ways, your walking on your own path and I was walking mine.
You wrote: "See? This is why you don’t go to the toilets alone." She had warned me.
It should be: "See? This is why you shouldn't go to the toilets alone." She had warned me.
The rest its all good..
Writing Style: 9/10
I love how you wrote the story. Its very nice.
Characterization: 8/10
I was sort of confuse, because i don't know which girl your talking about. You should have gave them names or make it specifically.
Communication With Readers: 5/5
The communication here is strong. The way you write your story just make me feel the story. So good job!
Overall Enjoyment: 4/5
I enjoyed reading your story although i prefer love/romance story better, but overall its great!
Bonus: +5
Total: 94/100

No comments:

Post a Comment